This completely reimagined home preserves the character and craftsmanship of its circa-1921 roots — set within Allentown's State & National Historic District — while delivering the systems, finishes, and comfort of new construction. From original hardwood and pocket doors to a fully renovated kitchen and brand-new mechanicals throughout, 135 South Main Street offers a rare opportunity: a truly historic home that lives like new.
Settled in the early 1700s around a mill built by Nathan Allen, Allentown grew into a thriving village of blacksmiths, wheelwrights, and tradespeople — and today remains one of Monmouth County's most treasured historic communities. Tucked into the western edge of the county and surrounded by a greenbelt of rich farmland, Allentown is home to one of New Jersey's most charming and walkable Main Streets.
The Allentown Historic District includes 225 homes on the State and National Registers, many dating before 1860, with 18th- and 19th-century architecture lining brick sidewalks and leafy streets. The Allentown Mill, dating to 1855, remains a centerpiece of the district and a National Register landmark. Today the town offers boutique shopping, beloved local restaurants, picturesque parks, and fishing at Connines Pond — all within a close-knit community that has protected its small-town character for centuries.
135 South Main Street, Allentown, NJ | Open House Sunday, August 16, 2026, 1–3 PM